Private health insurance in Australia is both widely misunderstood by the public and highly contentious in some respects.

The evidence clearly shows that private health insurance in Australia suffers from both a communication problem - many people simply don't understand what they're buying - and a legitimacy problem, with experts questioning its value and sustainability. This makes it one of the most misunderstood and debated aspects of Australia's entire Healthcare system.

Ultimately, given this present lack of understanding that most people have, they tend to not utilise the services available to them, or possibly believe they are "covered for everything", which may not be the case.

Let's take a walk through the current state of the private health insurance sector:

Clear Evidence of Public Confusion

Government Acknowledgment:

The Australian Government Department of Health directly states: "Australians have told us they find private health insurance complex and hard to understand what different policies cover and what they do not."

Survey Data on Understanding:

Recent surveys reveal alarming levels of confusion:

• 56% of individuals with private cover said they only partially understood the current tier framework
• 13% found the new system just as baffling as the old one, which varied wildly between insurers

Consumer Behavior Reflects Confusion:

The ACCC's annual report shows that half (48%) of private health insurance customers have thought about changing plans and took steps to do so, but only 14% followed through - suggesting people know they're dissatisfied but struggle to navigate alternatives.

Consumer Dissatisfaction with Policy Coverage:

Increased out-of-pocket costs are also a significant concern for many private health insurance policy holders, where there is a general feeling of lack of value-for-money. As a brief example of this, according to the July 2025 statistics reported by APRA, 15% of all services provided by healthcare providers require a gap payment, with this amounting to almost $86,000,000 in out-of-pocket costs of the 384,060 services provided, meaning that each service incurred an additional cost of $224.70 over and above the patient's policy cover (the "gap").

Historically, if you had have purchased a similar policy from a private healthcare provider twenty years ago, there would have likely been no gap whatsoever, with many consumers assessing the value of maintaining private healthcare.

It's Definitely a Contentious Topic

Academic Criticism:

Academic evidence shows that Australia's $6 billion annual subsidy to private health insurance is not value for money, creating significant policy debate.

Think Tank Opposition:

Progressive think tanks like The Australia Institute argue that "Private health insurance is a dud. That's why a majority of Australians don't have it".

System Sustainability Concerns:

The Grattan Institute warns that private health insurance is in a "death spiral" as young people opt out, worsening insurers' risk profiles.

Political Debate Gap:

Successive governments of both persuasions have failed to convincingly articulate why Australians need what is increasingly a duplicate health care system with duplicate costs.

Affordability Crisis:

The affordability of private health insurance is an issue for all Australians, going beyond just cost to questions of value and utility.

‍